Compare and contrast Antonio’s melancholy to that of Portia.

QuestionsCompare and contrast Antonio’s melancholy to that of Portia.
Andrew Jake resse asked 7 years ago

What are the similarities and differences between Antonio’s melancholy and that of Portia in Shakespeare’s play ‘The Merchant of Venice’?

10 Votes     ⇧ Upvote
2 Answers
Staff answered 7 years ago

In Shakespeare’s play The Merchant of Venice Antonio and Portia both are sad for their own reasons. We come to know of Antonio’s melancholy at the very beginning of the play. But Portia’s despair is made clear when the play progresses.

There are certain similarities in their melancholy.

  1. Portia and Antonio both share their sadness with those close to them. While Antonio talks with Solanio and Salarino, Portia finds support in Nerrisa.
  2. Both the characters are good in terms of virtue or morality and they themselves are not responsible for their melancholy. While for Portia it is her father who had made her bound by the terms of his will, it is the natural forces or some unknown reason that brings about Antonio’s sadness.
  3. Both are disturbed by their melancholy and wish to come out of this.

Now there are differences too.

  • Portia knows the reason of her sadness, but Antonio does not know why he is sad, as he expresses it in the Act I, Sc 1 of the play.

This is how Antonio puts it before Salarino and Solanio.

In sooth, I know not why I am so sad.
It wearies me; you say it wearies you.
But how I caught it, found it, or came by it,
What stuff ’tis made of, whereof it is born,
I am to learn.

But, here’s what portia says to Nerrisa:

O me, the word ‘choose!’ I may
neither choose whom I would nor refuse whom I
dislike; so is the will of a living daughter curbed
by the will of a dead father…

  • As Portia does know the reason behind her sadness, she also has a possible solution, or at least a hope, in her mind. But Antonio is in deep trouble as he has no clue about where his sadness comes from. That’s why he says:

I hold the world but as the world, Gratiano;
A stage where every man must play a part,
And mine a sad one.

  • Antonio’s condition indeed worsens due to the following events (news of the shipwrecks) in the play, but Portia’s melancholy goes away as Bassanio chooses the right casket to win her hand.
43 Votes     ⇧ Upvote 
kaf9953 answered 6 years ago

In scene 1 Antonio,the central character of the play,”The Merchant of Venice” is shown in a melancholic mood. Antonio himself reveals to his friends-Salanio and  Salarino that he does not really know the reason of his sadness he also shares his state  of confusion to them saying this feeling of sorrow is making him such a slow and dumb person that he feels like he has a lot more to know about himself in such a condition. somewhere deep down he does know that this sadness is due to the parting from his best friend,Bassanio. who was planning on trip to Belmont to woo his lady love Portia who was a richly left lady.whereas Portia expresses her sadness in form of weariness. she says she was tired and weary of this big world whereas her real reason for this feeling and  fear was the casket test laid down by her dead father as a will to marry Portia and also her thoughts on this will.she thinks that her rights to choose a perfect life partner was taken away by her father. there was a fear that she would have to live her life with a man who she did not love .little did she know that her father would never make any decisions which would bring misery in her life when but Nerrisa, Portia’s lady in waiting explained her father’s decision to Portia ,the wise lady did understand her fathers strategy to choose a right partner to marry her off even in his absence. Portia’s mood turned humorous as she and Nerrisa spoke of her suitors so far, whereas Antonio was still uncertain of his reasons for sadness.

13 Votes     ⇧ Upvote