The short story ‘Old Man at the Bridge’ is about relationship. Do you agree? Give reasons.

QuestionsThe short story ‘Old Man at the Bridge’ is about relationship. Do you agree? Give reasons.
Subir Das Roy asked 6 years ago

Earnest Hemingway’s story “Old Man at the Bridge” is all about relationship. Do you agree to this statement? Give reasons in support of your answer.

11 Votes     ⇧ Upvote
2 Answers
Staff answered 6 years ago

Well, though Hemingway’s story “Old Man at the Bridge” is mainly regarded as a powerful depiction of tragedy of war and how it impacts common people who are ‘without politics’, relationships have also been an important theme here.
In the story, we see the old man’s relationship with the animals. He repeats his concern for his pets a number of times while conversing with the narrator. He has no family but the animals — a cat, two goats and four pairs of pigeons. Those are his family. Now, as he is forced to leave the town because of the artillery, his pets are left on their fate. The man expresses his assurance that the cat can look after itself, but he is worried about the other animals. In fact, most part of the conversation is about the animals of the old man. That indicates how powerful the old man’s love is for his animals. 
Again, the author mentions the old man’s pleasure and his smile while mentioning his native town San Carlos. That again is about man’s love for his native land. When we are born and brought up at a place, we develop a powerful relationship with that place, with the people living there and the nature around. 
So, it won’t be wrong to conclude that Hemingway’s short story “Old Man at the Bridge” focuses on the theme of relationship.

51 Votes     ⇧ Upvote 
Yash answered 6 years ago

Yes, I agree. Although the primary theme of the story may not be relationships, it is definitely a secondary theme, the primary being the harmful atrocities of war and its impact on innocent civilians who have absolutely no political affiliations or bias.  The secondary is the relationship between the old man and his animals. The harsh reality that animals are the source of love, affection and companionship instead of other humans for many people and the realization that war between two factions has impact on people from all economic strata, especially the poor, helpless and old. The guilt the old man feels for leaving his dear animals deserted is proof of the solidity of their relationship.

46 Votes     ⇧ Upvote